Skip to main content

Because We Don’t Live in a Perfect World

SB 1338 has been on my mind since California Governor Gavin Newsom unveiled the policy known as the Community Assistance, Recovery, and Empowerment (CARE) Court in March 2022. Cutting through the verbiage from both supporters and opponents, CARE Court essentially creates a system of court-ordered medical treatment for up to twenty-four months when an individual—often unhoused and living with a psychotic disorder—is deemed unable to make medical decisions in their own best interest.

Photo by Matt Collamer on Unsplash

In the months that followed, organizations such as Human Rights Watch and the ACLU raised objections to the policy. I found myself dumbfounded by many of their arguments.

Some critics claimed there was insufficient evidence supporting SB 1338. Yet the evidence that the current system of social services and voluntary interventions is failing can be seen within the first few steps into Skid Row in downtown Los Angeles—a fifty-block district designated since 1976 to contain much of the county’s homeless population.

In truth, critics do not even need to walk through Skid Row.

Human and legal rights attorneys and advocates should spend a day walking and riding the L.A. Metro system. Start at Union Station and travel the lines branching toward Long Beach, Santa Monica, and North Hollywood. Spend a day observing what commuters see every day.


They should walk through homeless encampments without access to water or toilets. They should witness someone squatting in the middle of a crowded subway car to relieve themselves. They should see people eating from trash cans, screaming at everyone and at no one, or wandering into traffic. They should see people sleeping in trash bins or collapsed on scorching concrete in the middle of the street.

They should see the naked woman walking down a boulevard in full view of traffic. They should see pedestrians threatened, sometimes with sexual violence. They should see the father pulling his young daughter away as a man with his genitalia exposed approaches them.

In the decade I have lived in Los Angeles without a car, I have witnessed every one of these scenes.

Before raising objections from afar, those who argue against policies such as CARE Court should witness these conditions themselves—the inhumane living environments and the danger that untreated mental illness can pose both to those suffering from it and to the people around them.


Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass once framed the issue in a way that struck me as honest. Not every homeless person becomes homeless because of mental illness, and not every homeless person suffers from mental illness. Yet she also acknowledged something simple and human: living on the streets would break almost anyone.

Imagine the mental narratives one must construct simply to survive a night on the sidewalk. Imagine digging through trash for food or relieving yourself in public. Imagine the fear, anxiety, anger, and humiliation one must suppress day after day just to endure.

To believe that the trauma of living this way—layered on top of an existing psychotic disorder such as schizophrenia—would not impair someone’s ability to make medical decisions in their own best interest is naïve at best and negligent at worst.

Because we do not live in a perfect world.

And in an imperfect world, pretending that suffering does not exist is not compassion.

_____
More essays:

ESSAYS | RECIPES | STYLES | IG

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Confessions of a Former Poll Worker

The last federal election I recall working at the polls was on November 8, 2016. I was assigned to Los Feliz, often frequented by actors and musicians who lived in the lush hills above the neighborhood. I remember one particular actor from The Big Bang Theory who kept asking me if I really did not recognize him after I asked for his name. At the time, he was more of an annoyance as the line stretched out of the building and around the corner, and no, I had no idea who he was. Even after another volunteer whispered to me who he was, I just shrugged. He would still have to identify himself. I did not ask him for an identification card, which would have been illegal in California at the time. I asked for his name so I could locate him in the poll book for him to sign. Norton Simon Museum, Pasadena, California It became clear a few hours before the polls closed in California that Trump had won and that the hope of electing the first female President of the United States had collapsed. No...

Korean Gal's Guatemalan Red Beans with Pork Spare Ribs

Full transparency. I am afraid of pressure cookers. It is a fear instilled in me by my mom, a quiet but effective deterrent meant to keep me at a safe distance—especially when the pressure is being released. Reasonable? Perhaps. I would consider a therapist, but it has been years since I have needed one. Ceramic bowl was wheel-thrown and glazed by me. When I saw the Pressure Cooker Guatemalan Red Beans with Beef Short Ribs recipe in The World Central Kitchen Cookbook: Feeding Humanity, Feeding Hope , I knew I had to make a version of my own—one that did not require a pressure cooker. I also wanted the ingredients to feel simpler, more accessible. More importantly, I wanted the dish to center the red beans, rather than have them overshadowed by the richness of beef short ribs. This is not a bean stew, but a slow braise—one that relies on the gradual release of moisture from the ingredients themselves. So, changes were made—and thus, the name: Korean Gal’s Guatemalan Red Beans with P...

Carrot et Celery Ribbon Salad

Salade de carottes râpées carries the kind of understated elegance that French home cooking does so well: grated carrots dressed simply with vinaigrette, brightened with lemon, Dijon mustard, parsley, and sometimes a touch of shallot. It is neither elaborate nor fussy, yet that simplicity is precisely what makes it timeless. Crisp, earthy, lightly acidic, and quietly refreshing, the salad is often served alongside delicate white fish fillets prepared meunière-style, pan-fried in butter and finished with lemon and parsley, where its brightness cuts through the richness without overwhelming the plate. Borrowing from salade de carottes râpées, Carrot et Celery Ribbon Salad takes a slightly different form. The carrots and celery are ribboned with a vegetable peeler rather than shredded, allowing the vegetables to hold more texture and shape. The celery, in particular, adds a fresh crispness that cuts through the sweetness of the carrots, giving the salad a lighter, cleaner bite. INGREDIENT...

All Is Not Fair in Marriage, But Should You At Least Get Some Justice?

Marriage is complicated. It requires more than love to sustain it. Divorce is a lot more complicated. It is rare for a single reason alone to cause a divorce, at least for most of us. I used to get offended when people inquired about why I divorced. That offense itself was layered with a need for privacy, the rawness of processing emotional injuries, and the reality that I did not know why he left. The only certainty was that I couldn't trust him anymore. It took more than a decade for me to openly talk about it. I am amused by Heather Ammel v. Kyrsten Sinema . It has all the elements of a good Lifetime movie: a cheating husband, a former U.S. senator, and an allegedly devastated wife. It extends beyond emotion, with legal questions unfolding as former Senator Kyrsten Sinema seeks dismissal on the grounds that while the affair happened, it did not happen in North Carolina, and therefore the state law forming the basis of the lawsuit is out of its jurisdiction.  In North Carolin...

Should Los Angeles Remain a Sanctuary City?

I was coming out of a lovely restaurant in Downtown L.A.—Le Petit Paris. My Uber was waiting across the street, annoyingly parked on the wrong side of a one-way road. As I approached, a homeless man was shouting at the car. The driver didn’t move. Did he not realize I would have to walk right past a screaming, clearly distressed man just to get in? View of Los Angeles As soon as I closed the door, the driver apologized. He wasn’t sure he should even be driving. After his last ride in Old Town Pasadena, a homeless man had thrown something at his car, damaging it. He was still shaken. A few weeks earlier, someone had hurled a brick—or something like it—through his parked car window. For someone who drives full-time for rideshare, every dent or crack isn’t just an inconvenience; it’s a financial crisis. As an Angeleno, I’m often told I’m a rarity—I don’t drive. I gave up my car and license over a decade ago. I walk, take the Metro, and use rideshare. In many ways, I see more of this cit...

It Happens All the Time.

I have lived in Los Angeles for more than four decades. I slept in a van the night following the 1994 Northridge earthquake, which killed 57, injured more than 9,000, and caused over $13 billion in property damage. Some have published economic losses as high as $50 billion. View of Los Angeles from Runyon Canyon I was no different from many Angelenos. Wildfires and mudslides in our coastal and hillside neighborhoods were an inconvenience met with indifference. We saw them as a consequence of living with gorgeous views. Wildfires and mudslides could not have been much of a concern for those who bought and lived in high-risk communities. To claim otherwise would be obtuse, especially for those who owned properties without homeowner's insurance. That is like driving a car without insurance, even if the state lawfully allows it. I live among Progressives—people who claim to care about the environment, inclusiveness, and equality. I voted for Vice President Kamala Harris in the last pre...

Curated: Summer 2026 Style Makers

A change in season shouldn't require us to abandon the past that resides in our closets, but rather the addition of a piece or two to elevate our style for the upcoming season. With fast fashion, digital creators, and influencers, we have gotten lost in the chaos of “new,” “more,” and “outfit of the day,” as though something new every day itself is fashionable. Cancún, Mexico Fashion, one's style, is not and cannot be always new. One's style is a reflection of our personality, mood, and perception of ourselves. It is quite unrealistic and damaging to one's mental wellness if the expectation is to change every day—brand new everything. It is also very damaging to the earth, as pointed out in Guilt of Disposable Fashion . Fashion, style, is about curation—a collection that reflects our individualism rather than a bin of polyester. As summer approaches and you are taking inventory of the summer pieces in your closet and are in need of one or two pieces to elevate your styl...

Sweet & Spicy Chicken Drumsticks

Sweetness is most compelling when it follows heat. In cooking, it is a matter of balance; in life, a matter of survival. There are moments that feel less like hardship and more like an inferno—consuming, disorienting, and undeserved. We endure them not because we are prepared, but because there is no alternative. And even when the outcome falls short of what we were owed, something quieter can still emerge on the other side: a sweetness that is not victory, but reprieve. There are times when justice has to be redefined. We are taught to imagine it as consequence or vindication, yet lived experience often demands something more modest and more urgent. Sometimes justice is simply the ability to move forward without fear. To exist without bracing. To reclaim ordinary days. In those moments, sweetness is not indulgent—it is necessary. When this Sweet & Spicy Chicken Drumsticks recipe was developed, it felt like a translation of that tension. The heat was unmistakable. The sweetness...

Summer Capsule: Flip Flops et Sandals

Flip-flops and sandals once lived at the margins of style—practical, unassuming, and rarely invited into conversations about taste. They belonged to errands, beach days, and the quiet acceptance of comfort over consideration. To wear them beyond those boundaries felt, at best, indifferent and, at worst, careless. Kāʻanapali Beach, Maui Something shifted. What was once dismissed as too casual began to be reexamined through a different lens—one that values restraint over excess. Designers pared them down to their essentials, and in doing so, revealed a kind of clarity: clean lines, deliberate simplicity, and an ease that resists overthinking. In a landscape saturated with structure and embellishment, sandals and flip-flops offered something quietly radical—absence as intention. Now, they move with purpose through spaces that once excluded them—paired with tailored trousers, anchored beneath sharp silhouettes, and integrated into wardrobes that understand proportion and balance. They no l...

Jeju Linguine al Nero di Seppia: Gochujang Squid Pasta

Off the southern coast of the Korean peninsula lies Jeju Island, a place where the sea shapes both livelihood and cuisine. Among its prized catches is Jeju squid, known for its clean sweetness and tender bite—qualities that have long made it a favorite in Korean kitchens. Whether grilled over charcoal or gently simmered in spicy stews, Jeju squid carries the unmistakable flavor of the surrounding waters. Ceramic bowl was wheel-thrown and glazed by me. This dish brings that ingredient into a conversation between two culinary traditions. Linguine al nero di seppia, the Italian pasta tinted black with squid ink, becomes the canvas for a sauce layered with Korean flavors. The foundation begins with olive oil, onion, and garlic, followed by white wine and tomato paste that deepen in color as they cook. Then comes gochujang, whose fermented heat introduces the unmistakable character of Korean cooking. What makes the dish sing, however, is its balance. The richness of butter softens the inten...