Skip to main content

Impossibility of Jason Arday

When I first read about Jason Arday, he had just resigned from the University of Cambridge. Accusations of plagiarism reminded me of Claudine Gay, the former president of Harvard University, who resigned after accusations of plagiarism surfaced. There certainly was more to her resignation than accusations of plagiarism. She was also accused of antisemitism following her congressional testimony. Her story ended with her becoming the shortest-serving president in the history of Harvard.


When a second article about Arday caught my eye, he had been found dead at his home in South London. To this day, suicide has not been named as the cause of death, but I find myself speculating that it was suicide, given the circumstances surrounding his death and the absence of any reported foul play. I imagine many of us are wondering the same thing.

I think about his last days. On August 5, the university announced that it had accepted his resignation and would open an investigation into allegations concerning his academic qualifications and honorary appointments. He was found dead nine days later. It must have felt like hope being vacuumed out of his life, leaving nothing, not even anger. There is a certain calmness that cannot be explained unless experienced, one that can gently blanket a path toward death. Knowing that it will end, whatever “it” may be, can be soothing, quieting even the fear of the ultimate unknown: death. Words like painful and dark are inadequate to describe what it takes to choose death.

What he must've felt, and all that may have pushed him toward death, we helped create that.


I didn't know Jason Arday. When Cambridge appointed him Professor of Sociology of Education back in 2023, making him the youngest Black person ever appointed to a professorship at the University, it did not register in my newsfeed. Perhaps it did and I just don't recall.

We don't need to have known him. We don't have to be the individuals who accused him of lies, false claims, and plagiarism. Simply having complacently lived in a world where a Black man may have felt the need to lie about his life, even in part, to achieve, and then felt that achievement itself was not enough, until his accomplishments had to become extraordinary, perhaps even superhuman, just to stand shoulder-to-shoulder with his colleagues, makes us part of the world that created that pressure.

If you want to argue with me, start here: Only 0.3% of professors at Cambridge identify as Black. Consider the pressure he must've experienced as not only the university's youngest Black professor, but, as we now understand more clearly, one of its extraordinarily few Black professors.


He isn't getting a free pass from me because he is dead or because he is Black. He claimed to have been a visiting professor at Ohio State University's Office of Diversity and Inclusion. Ohio State confirmed that it had no record of Arday ever being employed there in any role. He also claimed to have been a visiting professor at the University of Glasgow. While he held a genuine professorship at Glasgow, the university denied that he had previously held a visiting professorship there. While he had worked at Durham University, his claim that he remained an honorary professor was also contradicted by the university. Birkbeck, University of London, told the Guardian it could find no record of Jason Arday having studied there, despite his claim that he had earned a master's degree in psychodynamic practices from the university.

He also claimed to be the author of a published book, Being Young, Black and Male: Challenging the Dominant Discourse, with Palgrave Macmillan. The publisher confirmed that it had accepted a proposal, but the book was never published. He had claimed that he ran 600 miles in six days, a claim later revised to 12 days. He apparently ran 30 marathons in 35 days, finishing the final nine after reportedly suffering a hairline leg fracture during an epileptic seizure. I'll quote ChatGPT on that particular claim: “Unconfirmed, but physically possible.”

The list of disputed and unconfirmed claims continues, somehow making the accusations of plagiarism pale beside the apparent embellishments and contradictions in his biography. He didn't need to lie. His confirmed academic accomplishments were significant without embellishment. He earned his PhD from Liverpool John Moores University. He was a Senior Lecturer at the University of Roehampton, an Associate Professor in Sociology at Durham University, and a Professor of Sociology of Education at the University of Glasgow before arriving at Cambridge to become its youngest Black professor.

So, why lie? And why lie about accomplishments that can so easily be verified through records?


Allegations of plagiarism are more complex than most of us presume. Arday received his PhD from Liverpool John Moores University back in 2015, and the university investigated his thesis when it first received allegations in 2023. It concluded that the problems it identified amounted to “honest and reasonable error” rather than research misconduct and did not revoke his doctorate. Two years later, the university received another allegation, which it found substantially overlapped with matters it had already investigated, and it did not open a new investigation. Earlier this year, allegations of plagiarism surfaced again, this time through outside scrutiny. In particular, the Telegraph reported finding more than one hundred passages in Arday's thesis that were identical or nearly identical to passages in an earlier thesis.

Plagiarism in academia is not black-and-white. There are varying degrees, and not every instance of unattributed or improperly attributed text is treated as deliberate academic misconduct. Is it possible that Liverpool John Moores University's investigation was biased in Arday's favor because he was Black? It is possible. Then isn't it also possible that the university may at times have been biased in the same way when investigating white scholars?

Didn't we in our diversity, equity, and inclusion programs ask for exceptions rather than fairness? And didn't that framing of exceptions in these programs make Arday a target? Not just a target of scrutiny, but also make him feel like he was given access he didn't earn and was given it because of the color of his skin? So, did he build a narrative that he didn't otherwise need in order to prove that access was earned?

And if so, didn't we make it impossible for Jason Arday to live the life he had earnestly earned?

_____
More essays:

ESSAYS | RECIPES | STYLES | IG

Articles sélectionnés
I earn commission on qualified purchases.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Art of Gifting: No Green Thumb Required

The holiday season is upon us, bringing with it a succession of occasions that gather friends, families, and coworkers. From Friendsgiving and Thanksgiving to Hanukkah, Christmas, and Kwanzaa, there is no shortage of reasons to celebrate and exchange gifts. There is great joy in finding something thoughtful to give, though the search for the right gift can sometimes feel like a holiday obligation of its own. Rolling Greens, Culver City, California That's why I'm starting this series, appropriately titled The Art of Gifting, to take some of the guesswork out of holiday shopping with a collection of thoughtful finds worth giving. We begin with plants, or more precisely, the people who love them. Houseplants have become something of a cultural phenomenon, moving well beyond their traditional role as decorative accents. From carefully curated indoor jungles to a single statement plant, greenery has become an integral part of how we personalize and bring life to our living spaces. B...

Her Self-Care Soup: Miyeokguk

Korean women have built quite a reputation for taking self-care seriously. Just look at the global fascination with K-beauty, elaborate skincare routines, and an industry seemingly determined to discover yet another way to preserve a youthful complexion. But the Korean approach to well-being extends well beyond what happens in front of a bathroom mirror. There is an entire postpartum care industry devoted to helping women recover after childbirth, because bringing a new life into the world is hardly a minor undertaking. And somewhere in this culture of caring for oneself, there is miyeok (미역), Korean sea mustard, and its starring role in miyeokguk (미역국). Ceramic bowl was wheel-thrown and glazed by me. Unlike dashi, the Japanese soup stock, or the broad assortment of seaweeds used in Asian cooking, miyeok occupies a particularly meaningful place in Korean kitchens. It is the essential ingredient in a soup traditionally served to women after giving birth, often multiple times a day durin...

Perhaps It Is Time for 007 Not to Be a White Man

Eight actors have portrayed James Bond on television and on the big screen since 1954: Barry Nelson, Sean Connery, David Niven, George Lazenby, Roger Moore, Timothy Dalton, Pierce Brosnan, and Daniel Craig. While I haven't seen all eight in action as 007, Pierce Brosnan has always been my favorite. If you've ever seen him in person, he might become yours, too. It has been nearly three decades since I saw him, but I remember it as though it were yesterday: impossibly handsome, perfectly put together, and every bit as gorgeous in person as one might imagine. Some impressions, apparently, are not subject to expiration. William Andrew Clark Memorial Library After a five-year hiatus, the James Bond franchise has once again given the gossip mill something to work with. Reports of screen tests for the coveted role surfaced last month, with an announcement of the next 007 anticipated by the end of this year. The names circulating include Callum Turner, Jack Lowden, Josh O'Connor, R...

Jensen Huang's Ego & Sexpionage

Jensen Huang, Nvidia's co-founder and now former CEO, mastered the art of commanding attention. The signature leather jackets, the hands-on management style, the charismatic stage presence, and an intelligence delivered with uncommon approachability made him one of the most recognizable figures in technology. He cultivated a persona as distinctive as Nvidia's rise itself, becoming the face of an artificial intelligence revolution that has moved from the realm of technological promise into the fabric of our everyday lives. at LACMA I doubt many of us were shocked when news of his affair with Alice Huang made headlines. Men have affairs. Men worth billions of dollars have affairs. And when one affair became affairs, plural, I don't think many of us were particularly surprised. Bill Gates, Jeff Bezos, Sergey Brin, and Silvio Berlusconi are just a handful of billionaires whose romantic indiscretions became public scandals. Jensen Huang, however, managed to take the familiar bil...

Come Rain or Couture

Before rain boots became a fashion statement, they were a matter of preservation. In the nineteenth century, women navigating muddy streets had to contend with delicate shoes that were hardly equipped for the elements. Pattens, wooden-soled overshoes that elevated footwear above the muck, offered one solution; rubber galoshes offered another. The invention of vulcanized rubber in 1839 changed the equation, making waterproof footwear considerably more durable and commercially viable. What followed was the evolution of the Wellington boot, a design with decidedly aristocratic and military beginnings that would eventually find its way from the countryside into women's wardrobes. Mexico City, Mexico For much of their existence, rubber boots were valued for what they could withstand rather than how they looked. They belonged to farms, gardens, military trenches, and rainy country estates. But fashion has a peculiar talent for rehabilitating the practical. By the mid-twentieth century, t...

Please Normalize Sex

I couldn't help feeling that Shane Gillis's monologue on the October 10 episode of Saturday Night Live was a stab at the alleged victim of the Cornell University gang rape case and the uproar surrounding it. Of course, I have no idea what he intended, other than to be funny, when he said, “I haven't been to the gym in so long, I didn't know women just dress like whores now?” But the joke played into a familiar narrative, one in which women's clothing and sexuality become measures of their character, and sometimes even their credibility. With Jane Doe and her attorney reportedly receiving death threats amid the controversy, the timing struck me as particularly distasteful. at LACMA Perhaps my problem is that there was simply nothing funny about it. Not because he called women whores, but because the joke failed to land. Strip away the provocation, and what remains? A rather pedestrian observation about women's gym attire, masquerading as comedy. Very weak. I get...

Crunchy Pork Belly Kimbap

You may recognize him from Season Two of Netflix’s Culinary Class Wars, but I first came across him on 냉장고를 부탁해, also known internationally as Please Take Care of My Refrigerator and Chef & My Fridge. If you haven't watched the weekly show, it's also available on Netflix. By now, you may be wondering who I'm talking about. Is it Chef Son Jong-Won, the acclaimed chef behind two Michelin-starred restaurants? No, I'm talking about Chef Jung Ho-Young. Widely regarded as one of South Korea's leading chefs specializing in Japanese cuisine, Chef Jung is known for his sense of humor and his unabashed love of food. And I mean that quite literally: he loves eating as much as he loves cooking. Chef Jung was the inspiration behind this Crunchy Pork Belly Kimbap. In a recent episode of Please Take Care of My Refrigerator, which hasn't yet become available on Netflix, he prepared a gigantic kimbap that caught my attention. I liked the idea of his creation and decided to t...

Who Investigated the Alleged Cornell Gang Rape?

This morning, my mind froze as I read about an alleged gang rape involving eight Cornell University students that occurred nearly two years ago, in 2024. Most of us learned the details only after Jane Doe filed a civil lawsuit on September 14, 2026, in New York State Supreme Court, New York County, against Matthew Ingalls, Johnathan Newell, Winston Lee, Gillio Lopes, Diego Sarabia, Scott Norris, and Scott Kretzschmar, alleging that the seven men raped her while they were students at Cornell University. The alleged assault occurred during the night of October 19 into the morning of October 20, 2024. Jane Doe later reported the incident to Cornell University Police. Cornell separately conducted its own disciplinary investigation, followed by hearings under its Title IX process, while Cornell University Police conducted the criminal investigation that was referred to the Tompkins County District Attorney’s Office. at LACMA No criminal charges followed. The District Attorney’s Office did n...

The Grandeur of Mundaneness

Whenever I think of the word mundane, I think of Burning, the film starring Yoo Ah In. It was described once as being like watching paint dry. That comparison lingered. In many ways, the pandemic years felt the same—new coats layered endlessly over the wall, each variant stripping away the hope that the surface might finally harden. Kaanapali It feels almost obtuse to call the pandemic mundane. More than five million lives lost. Hundreds of millions infected. At moments, it threatened not just our survival, but our humanity—our ability to remain human, with hearts and intelligence intact. The first months were brutal. Our lives collapsed inward, reduced to rooms, screens, and routines that repeated without distinction. Before all of this, I had built a life around the belief that life itself is art, paired with a devotion to minimalism. I found serenity in ordinary things: cooking, reading, knitting, tending to plants, coloring, crafting. Even cleaning brought a quiet satisfaction, pun...

Cilantro Chili Sauce

The blender was already out on the counter, liberated from its usual spot on the shelf, and half a bunch of cilantro lingered from my Piri-Piri recipe testing. The stage, also known as the kitchen counter, was set. So I figured: why not? A few minutes of tinkering later, a vibrant green chili sauce came to life. This little burst of flavor, confetti-like, goes well with just about everything, but be warned: it’s highly addictive spooned over warm basmati rice. Consider yourself warned. Just blend all the ingredients listed below in a blender.  INGREDIENTS a garlic clove a half bunch of cilantro, roughly chopped a serrano pepper a red pepper a shallot, halved a lime, juiced a half cup of extra virgin olive oil a half teaspoon of salt, plus a pinch or two more to taste a Calabrian cherry chili pepper (from a jar) _____ More recipes: Eggplant & Zucchini Gnocchi French Drumstick: Pan-Seared Duck Leg with Butter, Garlic, and Herbs Pyrus Pyrifolia Tuna Salad Sandwich Langostino Gnocc...