Skip to main content

My Last Gift to Dad Was a Do-Not-Resuscitate Order

When Dr. Moon, a pain management specialist, told me about Dad’s wish, it was not the first time I had heard it. A few days earlier, Mom had told me that Dad wanted to be transferred from the hospital to hospice. I did not quite understand what hospice meant at the time. Between that conversation with Mom and the one with Dr. Moon, I had watched Dad take about twenty steps with the support of a walker and the assistance of a physical therapist. After seeing him come out of critical condition, I took those steps as a sign of recovery. So I was surprised when Dr. Moon told me that Dad had expressed his wish to end all medical treatments and go peacefully.


I had been struggling with the continuation of his medical treatment. Three days after I wrote Will Love Give Us the Courage to Let Our Dad Go?, Dad passed away peacefully, as though he had simply fallen asleep, with a morphine drip erasing the pain that had once dominated him. He was eighty years old and had spent the last six years of his life battling an autoimmune disease that shrank his body by half and, at moments, took dignity from a proud man.

Our family did not have a palliative care plan for him. My brother, who was Dad’s medical advocate, could not accept that it was time for us to let Dad go. He understood that it was the best thing we could do for him, but he could not accept it emotionally. Mom understood too, but she could not bring herself to do it. So I was left to manage Dad’s last days. I am the pragmatic one in the family.

The day before he passed away, I was at the hospital at 5:30 a.m. Did you know that some doctors start making rounds at 6 a.m.? I wanted to be there to meet every doctor and understand every treatment being offered to, and declined by, Dad. By then, he was irritated. He was suspicious that we would force more medical treatment on him. He refused to let a nurse check on him until I explained that the nurse had to check on him, and that refusing care altogether could trigger a discharge from the hospital before hospice was in place. When he immediately calmed down and let the nurse come to his bedside, I knew he was coherent. I knew he understood the consequences of his decision.


As each doctor came and went, as Dad refused treatments, as he allowed nurses and phlebotomists to do their work only after I explained that these were not the interventions he was trying to refuse, I realized there was nothing left for me to do but ask for all acute medical treatment to end and make sure he received the best comfort care available. After the palliative care consult, I asked Dad one more time. He was certain.

When the hospice admitting nurse explained the process to me, I was fine. My emotions detached, as though I were sitting in a business meeting while someone explained something that was never going to happen. My Dad was not going to die. I had been told numerous times by doctors that he would not live beyond a day, perhaps two. I understood that. I even found my brother, who kept insisting that Dad could easily live another week or more, irritating. But my heart kept believing Dad would live, even as my brain believed the doctors.

As I signed one document after another, from the service agreement to the insurance forms, I was fine. It was something I had to do. It had nothing to do with what I wanted. It had everything to do with abiding by Dad’s wishes and ensuring the best comfort care. I had been advised that the best hospice care was in-hospital hospice care, so I took comfort in knowing that I was getting him the best hospice care available. He did not have to be transferred to a hospice facility. He could remain at the hospital and receive comfort care there.


It was not until I reached the last document that I broke. It was a one-page document. While all the others had been signed electronically, this one was a hard copy. It began with a do-not-resuscitate order, followed by a list of interventions being declined, including feeding tubes. There would be no further medical intervention to keep Dad alive, only care to keep him comfortable. It was the first time I became upset. I cried as I signed the form and left the room. I power-walked to Dad’s hospital room, crying. I remember telling him what I had done and that he had to be peaceful. That was what he could do for me.

I was angry. It was not sadness. I was angry that the only thing I could do for him was give up on him. I signed my name declining medical interventions that could possibly have kept Dad alive for a few more hours, days, or weeks. That night, Dad left further wishes, a verbal will, surrounded by his wife of more than fifty-five years, his children, and his grandchildren. I spent the night at the hospital, beside his bed. The next morning, he asked for Mom. She rushed over. They said their goodbyes. When she stepped away, his breathing became infrequent. He became unresponsive and lost consciousness. He took his last breath with Mom and me by his side.

As I watched Dad drift toward his last breath, I cried. The helplessness that had been anger the day before had become sadness. I apologized to him that all I could do for him was let him go. The head nurse called the time of death at 11:55 a.m., and I remained by his side until they took him to the mortuary.

As the days pass, I have my good and bad days. The pain of agreeing to cease acute treatment in exchange for comfort care broke my heart. I wanted to scream, “Please help him,” as he drifted toward death, but I could not because of what I had agreed to. That destroyed me. I know Dad went peacefully, with the best care. I know he had the chance to say goodbye to those he loved. I know he took his last breath with his family beside him. Yet I remain broken, frozen with doubt and what-ifs. Was my last gift to Dad the right gift?

_____
More essays:

ESSAYS | RECIPES | STYLES | IG

Articles sélectionnés
I earn commission on qualified purchases.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Please Normalize Sex

I couldn't help feeling that Shane Gillis's monologue on the October 10 episode of Saturday Night Live was a stab at the alleged victim of the Cornell University gang rape case and the uproar surrounding it. Of course, I have no idea what he intended, other than to be funny, when he said, “I haven't been to the gym in so long, I didn't know women just dress like whores now?” But the joke played into a familiar narrative, one in which women's clothing and sexuality become measures of their character, and sometimes even their credibility. With Jane Doe and her attorney reportedly receiving death threats amid the controversy, the timing struck me as particularly distasteful. at LACMA Perhaps my problem is that there was simply nothing funny about it. Not because he called women whores, but because the joke failed to land. Strip away the provocation, and what remains? A rather pedestrian observation about women's gym attire, masquerading as comedy. Very weak. I get...

12 Timeless Sweaters

Somewhere in my closet is a black cashmere sweater I picked up at a sample sale well over a decade ago. It is asymmetric, beautifully understated, and now held together in a few places by my own handiwork: a needle, black thread, and the firm conviction that some things are simply worth saving. I have mended it rather than replaced it, not because black cashmere sweaters are particularly difficult to find, but because this particular one is impossible to replace. at The Geffen Contemporary at MOCA At this point, it has become something of a comfort sweater. The sort I reach for when I want to feel entirely like myself, without the fuss of getting dressed and with all the pleasure of looking effortlessly put together. Fashion has a remarkable talent for convincing us that last season's treasures are this season's embarrassments. My old cashmere sweater has spent more than a decade making a rather persuasive argument to the contrary. It has survived changing trends, wardrobe purg...

Haemul Pajeon, Korean Seafood Green Onion Pancake

Whoever coined the phrase “bigger is better” clearly never consulted a five-foot-three-inch woman. I have long maintained that fabulousity often comes in small packages. There are exceptions, of course, and Haemul Pajeon, the Korean Seafood Green Onion Pancake, makes a rather delicious case for abandoning my principles. When it comes to this Korean favorite, thickness is everything. Packed with shrimp, squid, green onions, zucchini, and yellow onions, these savory pancakes are a glorious celebration of excess, at least where ingredients are concerned. While many recipes favor thinner pancakes or arrange the ingredients neatly on top, there is a reason the thicker, generously stuffed versions served at Korean restaurants have gone viral. With their crisp, deeply browned exteriors giving way to tender, seafood-packed interiors, they deliver a combination of flavor and texture that thinner versions simply cannot match. Sometimes, bigger really is better. Or, in this case, thicker. INGREDI...

The Art of Calabrian Chicken

I spent yesterday afternoon at the Lucas Museum of Narrative Art. Newly opened last month after years of anticipation, it was a visit I approached with some hesitation. My disappointment with LACMA's David Geffen Galleries earlier this year had yet to settle. I felt as though I had wandered into a fabulous space where art and artifacts had been arranged without much intention, without stories to tell, rather like an art fair with booths. I carried that impression with me as I prepared to visit the Lucas Museum. After the Prom by Norman Rockwell I knew I would be mesmerized by its architecture. What surprised me was the storytelling within. I hadn't expected Norman Rockwell's gallery to captivate me quite as much as it did. There was something profoundly beautiful about the smallness of life he portrayed, the ordinary moments of family, childhood, and everyday rituals elevated into something worthy of our attention. Rockwell's America was often idealized, certainly, bu...

Style Capsule: All Black

When Coco Chanel introduced her little black dress in 1926, she did more than offer women another wardrobe option. She helped transform a color long associated with mourning and solemnity into a symbol of modern elegance, independence, and sophistication. American Vogue famously compared the deceptively simple design to Ford's Model T, recognizing its potential to become a universal fashion essential. Nearly a century later, the little black dress remains indispensable, although Chanel deserves credit not only for perfecting the little black dress, but for recognizing that its greatest luxury was its simplicity. Women in Tub by Wayne Thiebaud Black's relationship with fashion, however, stretches much further back than Chanel's timeless silhouette. During the Renaissance, achieving a rich, consistent black required expensive dyes and considerable craftsmanship, making the color a conspicuous declaration of wealth and privilege. European monarchs and aristocrats adopted black...

Fiercely Chic in Leather

Long before leather became synonymous with rebellion and sex appeal, it was a marker of wealth and social standing. In eighteenth- and nineteenth-century Europe, finely crafted leather gloves were indispensable accessories for women of privilege, signaling refinement and the luxury of hands unaccustomed to manual labor. How amusing that a material once associated with proper etiquette would eventually become one of fashion's most provocative expressions of independence. Leather, it seems, has always understood the importance of making an impression, even as its definition of good manners has changed rather dramatically. Paris, France By the twentieth century, leather had shed much of its polite disposition. Yves Saint Laurent brought motorcycle-inspired rebellion into the hallowed world of Christian Dior in 1960, while Vivienne Westwood later embraced leather's more subversive possibilities through punk and fetish-inspired fashion. Azzedine Alaïa sculpted it around the femal...

What If I Told You Tolerance Is Insane

A few years ago, I worked as a Project Manager for a marketing agency. What most people did not know was that I wasn’t simply managing marketing projects. Part of my job was to conduct root-cause analysis and privately address what I found with the VP of Operations. The agency was losing clients, and part of my assignment was to conduct root-cause analysis within the PMO. No one ever told me the two were connected, but I wondered whether leadership believed they might be. Ganna Walska Lotusland I worked alongside another Project Manager, a smart guy with a project management certification whose vertical happened to be one of the problematic ones. He didn’t know that evaluating his project pipeline was part of my assignment. His failure to follow project management best practices had already been escalated. He also had reluctance to escalate problems early enough to keep them from affecting clients. One Client Success Manager was a recurring problem. She routinely failed to turn in ...

Curated Boots: From Ankle to Attitude

My first real memory of fashion begins with boots. I was still in elementary school, before my family immigrated to the United States, when my mom had a winter suit custom-made for me: dark red, two pieces, a blazer paired with a pleated mini skirt. Then came the styling decision that mattered most to me, a pair of red knee-high boots. For a little girl, the look was rather fashion-forward, and I adored it. I wore those boots practically everywhere, long after the suit had ceased to be the point. I have insisted on boots ever since, with a fairly consistent personal rule: the longer, the better. at Donum Estate, Sonoma, California There was, as it turns out, some fashion logic behind my childhood obsession. Boots have always carried more weight than most shoes, literally and symbolically. Born from utility, riding, military dress, and protection, they became increasingly expressive as women’s fashion changed, particularly in the 1960s, when rising hemlines gave tall boots new authority...

Who Investigated the Alleged Cornell Gang Rape?

This morning, my mind froze as I read about an alleged gang rape involving eight Cornell University students that occurred nearly two years ago, in 2024. Most of us learned the details only after Jane Doe filed a civil lawsuit on September 14, 2026, in New York State Supreme Court, New York County, against Matthew Ingalls, Johnathan Newell, Winston Lee, Gillio Lopes, Diego Sarabia, Scott Norris, and Scott Kretzschmar, alleging that the seven men raped her while they were students at Cornell University. The alleged assault occurred during the night of October 19 into the morning of October 20, 2024. Jane Doe later reported the incident to Cornell University Police. Cornell separately conducted its own disciplinary investigation, followed by hearings under its Title IX process, while Cornell University Police conducted the criminal investigation that was referred to the Tompkins County District Attorney’s Office. at LACMA No criminal charges followed. The District Attorney’s Office did n...

No Rice, No Deal Stir-Fry Bowl

For a while, I restrained myself from using salt and pepper in my cooking, partly because I had come to think of them as the two most overused seasonings, capable of keeping a dish from becoming more interesting than the obvious. At one point, I even wondered whether I had developed a sensitivity to salt; the slightest over-seasoning began tasting bitter to me. Salty filets at Michael Mina at Bellagio and Delilah at Wynn Las Vegas last year did little to repair the relationship. Trust me, an overly salted filet at an upscale restaurant is its own particular trauma, quite different from realizing the horrible flavor of McDonald’s new limited-edition Spicy Chicken McNuggets. I never abandoned salt entirely. I continued using it to enhance other spices and ingredients, but deliberately salty flavors, even those built around soy sauce, became increasingly rare in my kitchen. Ceramic bowl was wheel-thrown and glazed by me. Until recently. No Rice, No Deal Stir-Fry Bowl is deliberately veg...